Home / Knowledge base / PEOs

PEOs

Why are two PEO workers' comp quotes different on the same census?

Two PEO workers' comp quotes differ because underwriters rarely see the same risk, even when you show them the same census. Each quote depends on the class codes applied, how much payroll is assigned to each code, and the rates used in each state. Until you audit those and separate insurance costs from administrative fees, two quotes aren't a valid comparison.

Published

How much does workers' comp matter when choosing a PEO?

It depends on the work your employees do. For tech or professional services companies, workers' comp barely moves the decision. For others, like manufacturing, it can materially change the economics of the whole PEO.

What should you audit in each workers' comp quote?

Ask both PEOs for a breakdown of how they arrived at their number, then check:

  1. Which class codes are being used. A class code is the classification for the type of work an employee does, and it drives the rate applied to the payroll assigned to it.
  2. How much payroll is assigned to each code.
  3. What rate is applied in each state.
  4. Which charges are insurance costs, and which are administrative fees.
  5. Whether you're getting credit for a clean claims history. Your current policy may carry discounts for having no claims in recent years, and people often forget to include them in the side-by-side.

If the class codes or payroll assumptions differ between the two quotes, you still don't have a valid comparison.

What risk support should you ask about?

  1. How are claims handled?
  2. What safety resources are included?
  3. What happens to open claims if we leave?

Paychex, for example, references a PEO master workers' comp policy and says clients on it may get support from a safety representative, along with claims and reporting support. In Steve's experience, both Paychex and Insperity handle this well. The question is how well each one's support matches your exposure.

Is the cheaper workers' comp quote the better one?

Not automatically. The better PEO for workers' comp isn't the one with the lower total. It's the one whose quote is accurate for the work your employees perform, and whose risk support matches your exposure. A low quote built on the wrong class codes isn't a saving.

Adapted from Steve's video Paychex vs Insperity: How to Review the Two Models, chapter 8:29-9:58.

How Thinq is paidDepending on the service, Thinq may receive carrier commissions, referral fees, partner compensation or direct client fees. None of those relationships require you to use a specific carrier, platform, PEO or payroll provider. We work with the providers you already use when they fit, and we recommend alternatives when something is a better match on cost, service, administration and the needs of your business.

Common questions

Why is one PEO's workers' comp quote so much lower?

Usually different class codes, different payroll assigned to each code, different state rates, or fees mixed in with insurance costs. Audit all four.

Does workers' comp matter when choosing a PEO?

For tech and professional services, rarely much. For manufacturing and other higher-risk work, it can change the economics.

What is a workers' comp class code?

The classification for the type of work an employee does. It drives the rate applied to the payroll assigned to it.

Do we lose our clean claims discount if we join a PEO?

Ask. Your current policy may carry no-claims discounts that should be reflected in the comparison.

Steve Taylor

Steve Taylor

Steve Taylor, founder of Thinq HR & Insurance Services, has 15 years in employee benefits, HR, payroll, PEOs and insurance, including time inside Paychex, ADP and TriNet.

Not sure what you need? Good. That's where we come in.

Most companies come to us knowing something isn't working, not knowing which service to buy. We'll help you figure it out first.